Authors

  • Jo Michell

    Professor of Economics, The University of the West of England, Bristol

  • Rob Calvert Jump

    Associate Professor , The Institute of Political Economy, Governance, Finance and Accountability, University of Greenwich

Be the first to know about our upcoming events, new publications and recently added commentary.

Sign up to our newsletter

We only send emails once every two weeks to keep you up to date.
Sign Up

The Dangerous Fiction of the “Fiscal Black Hole”

Authors

  • Jo Michell

    Professor of Economics, The University of the West of England, Bristol

  • Rob Calvert Jump

    Associate Professor , The Institute of Political Economy, Governance, Finance and Accountability, University of Greenwich

New research, published today by the Progressive Economy Forum, shows that the widely- reported £50bn “hole” in the public finances, is the result of government accountancy rules and highly uncertain forecasts, not tax or spending decisions.

Using official forecasts from the Office for Budget Responsibility, economists Dr Jo Michell and Dr Rob Calvert Jump show that small changes in forecasts for future interest rates and growth, and what is counted as government debt, dramatically alter the size of the apparent “hole” in the public finances.

These changes to forecasts and accountancy rules produce hugely bigger effects than the £50bn or more changes in spending and taxes the government is reported to be considering for the Autumn Statement.

Most dramatically, reversing a decision to exclude the Bank of England’s debt from the government’s own debt figure, made in January 2022, completely wipes out the projected “fiscal hole” and, on the official forecasts, leaves the government with an additional £14bn to spend against its own debt targets by 2027.

Examples of minor changes, relative to the government’s current forecasts, are shown in the modelling results below.

1. A small increase in the government’s forecast borrowing costs makes the path of future debt unsustainable, making the target useless.

2. Slight changes in the forecast rate of growth, including a possible recession, mean the government also miss its target, also making the target useless.

3. Changing the accountancy rule used to measure the government debt back to what it was before Autumn Statement 2021 completely removes the “black hole”, putting government debt back on a sustainable footing with £64bn headroom to spare.

Download pdf here

Phoot credit flickr

Related Content

Authors

  • Patrick Allen

    Chair and Founder of PEF

  • Jo Michell

    Professor of Economics, The University of the West of England, Bristol

  • Kate Pickett

    Professor of Epidemiology at the University of York

  • Will Hutton

    Co-chair of the Purposeful Company. Principal Hertford College Oxford 2015- 2020, Co-founder of the Big Innovation Centre

  • Stephany Griffith-Jones

    Financial Markets Director at the Initiative for Policy Dialogue at Columbia University

  • Stewart Lansley

    Visiting fellow at the University of Bristol.

PEF Newsletter

Receive updates on our latest news and events.

We use cookies to personalise your experience, by using our website you agree to the terms and conditions set out in our privacy policy.